As an inventor, you've likely poured your heart and soul into creating a product that solves a problem or meets a need in the market. Now that you have a prototype and perhaps even a patent, you're faced with a critical decision: should you manufacture and sell the product yourself, or license it to another company?
Both options have their advantages and disadvantages, and the choice depends on a range of factors, such as your resources, goals, skills, and risk tolerance. In this blog post, we'll explore the pros and cons of manufacturing and selling your own product versus licensing it, and help you make an informed decision.
Manufacturing and Selling Your Own Product
Pros:
-
Control: When you manufacture and sell your own product, you have complete control over the design, quality, branding, pricing, distribution, and customer experience. You can make changes and improvements quickly and adapt to market feedback.
-
Profit: When you sell your own product, you get to keep all the profits, minus the production and marketing costs. This can be particularly rewarding if you have a high-margin product or a niche market.
-
Learning: Manufacturing and selling your own product can be a valuable learning experience, as it allows you to gain firsthand knowledge of the product, market, and customers. You can also develop new skills in areas such as production, logistics, finance, and sales.
Cons:
-
Investment: Manufacturing and selling your own product requires a significant investment of time, money, and resources, especially in the early stages. You need to pay for prototyping, production, inventory, packaging, shipping, and marketing, among other expenses.
-
Risk: Manufacturing and selling your own product also entails a high level of risk, as there's no guarantee that your product will be successful in the market. You may face competition, pricing pressures, regulatory hurdles, or other challenges that can eat into your profits or even bankrupt your business.
-
Scalability: Manufacturing and selling your own product can be limited by your capacity and reach. You may struggle to scale up production, expand to new markets, or compete with larger and more established players.
Licensing Your Product
Pros:
-
Resources: Licensing your product to another company can provide you with access to a wider range of resources, such as manufacturing facilities, distribution networks, marketing expertise, and financial support. This can help you overcome some of the barriers to entry and accelerate your time to market.
-
Income: Licensing your product can also generate income for you in the form of licensing fees and royalties. You can negotiate favorable terms with the licensee and earn a percentage of the sales revenue without having to bear the production and marketing costs.
-
Risk-sharing: Licensing your product can also help you share the risks and rewards of the product with the licensee. The licensee may have more experience, resources, and reputation in the market, and can leverage your product to enhance their own brand and revenue.
Cons:
-
Control: Licensing your product means that you give up some control over the product and its branding, pricing, quality, and distribution. You need to trust the licensee to uphold your vision and values and to act in your best interest.
-
Revenue-sharing: Licensing your product also means that you share the revenue with the licensee. The terms of the licensing agreement can vary widely, and you may not get as much income as you would if you sold the product yourself.
-
Dependence: Licensing your product also means that you become dependent on the licensee for the success of the product. If the licensee fails to execute or market the product effectively, or if the market conditions change, your income and reputation may suffer.
How to Decide: Manufacturing and Selling Your Own Product vs. Licensing?
Now that we've discussed the pros and cons of manufacturing and selling your own product versus licensing it, you may wonder how to decide which path is right for you. Here are some factors to consider:
-
Your goals: What are your long-term goals for the product? Do you want to build a brand and a company around it, or do you want to focus on inventing and creating new products?
-
Your resources: What resources do you have available to you, such as time, money, skills, and network? Do you have the expertise and capacity to manufacture and sell your own product, or do you need external help?
-
Your market: What is the demand and competition in your market? Is there a gap that your product fills, or is the market saturated? Can you differentiate your product from others and create a unique value proposition?
-
Your risk tolerance: How much risk are you willing to take on? Are you comfortable with the uncertainty and variability of manufacturing and selling your own product, or do you prefer a more predictable and stable income stream?
-
Your preferences: What is your personal preference and passion? Do you enjoy the creative and entrepreneurial aspects of manufacturing and selling your own product, or do you prefer to focus on the invention and ideation side?
Examples of Successful Inventors Who Chose Different Paths
To illustrate the different paths of manufacturing and selling your own product versus licensing it, let's look at some examples of successful inventors who chose each path:
-
Manufacturing and selling your own product: Sara Blakely, the founder of Spanx, invented a new type of shapewear that was more comfortable and effective than traditional garments. Instead of licensing her idea to a bigger company, she decided to start her own business and manufacture and sell the product herself. She invested $5,000 of her own savings and worked from her apartment to develop the prototype and the branding. Today, Spanx is a multi-million-dollar company with a wide range of products and a global reach.
-
Licensing your product: James Dyson, the inventor of the bagless vacuum cleaner, chose to license his technology to a Japanese company called Apex in the early 1990s, after failing to find a UK-based manufacturer. The licensing deal allowed Dyson to earn royalties from the sales of the product and to focus on developing new inventions. Later, Dyson started his own company, which became a major player in the vacuum and home appliances market.
Conclusion
As an inventor, deciding whether to manufacture and sell your own product or license it to another company is a crucial step in bringing your invention to the market. Both options have their merits and challenges, and the choice depends on a range of factors, such as your goals, resources, market, risk tolerance, and preferences. By considering the pros and cons and examining the examples of successful inventors, you can make an informed and confident decision that aligns with your vision and values.